The module described in this chapter offers the means to describe music in so-called ‘Common Music Notation’ (CMN, sometimes referred to as ‘Common Western Music Notation’). For this purpose, it provides a number of special elements and adds several attribute classes to elements from the
Shared Concepts in MEI module.
This chapter is supposed to frame the repertoire target by the module, i.e. what is Common Music Notation?
4.2. Basic Elements of CMN
This section describes the use of basic features of MEI important for encoding CMN material. Most of the elements discussed here are defined in chapter
Shared Concepts in MEI of these Guidelines, but are used in music from the CMN repertoire in specialized ways.
4.2.1. The Role of the Measure Element
Arguably, the most important element of the CMN module is the
measure element. It is used as a structural unit inside
section elements and acts as a container for ‘events’ from the
model.eventLike class, such as notes, chords and rests as well as ‘control events’ from the
model.controlEventLike class, such as slurs and indications of dynamics.
The following example demonstrates the use of the
measure slices the flow of a score or part into chunks that normally comply with a duration determined by the meter defined within a preceding
staffDef element. Each staff in the source material is represented by a
staff element. As the order of the staff elements in the file does not have to reflect their order in the original document, to eliminate confusion they should always refer to a
staffDef element, using either an @n or @def attribute. Whereas the @def attribute uses the xs:anyURI datatype, the @n value refers to the closest preceding
layerDef with the same value in its @n attribute.
staff may hold a number of
layer elements to reflect multiple ‘voices’. Just as with
staff, the order of the
layer elements in the file does not have to reflect their original order in the document, so they also possess @n and @def attributes for association with the appropriate layer definition.
There are other attributes that allow the specification of many further details of a score. These are available from the element definitions accessible at
When content is provided for
scoreDef, it must contain a
staffGrp element. This element is used to gather individual staves and other staff groups. This is useful for collecting instrumental or vocal groups in a large score, such as woodwinds, brasses, etc., and for assigning a shared label to the group, using the
labelAbbr subelements. The
staffGrp element is also used for the two staves of a grand staff. The @bar.thru attribute on
staffGrp allows one to specify whether barlines are drawn across the space between staves of that group or only on the staves themselves.
staffDef element is used to describe an individual staff of a
score or performer
part. It bears most of the attributes described above. The
labelAbbr subelements may be used for providing staff labels for the first and subsequent systems.
staffDef must have an @n attribute with an integer as its value. The first occurence of a
staffDef with a given number must also indicate the number of staff lines via the @lines attribute.
The order of
staffDef elements within
scoreDef follows the order of staves in the source document or planned rendering. The individual
staff elements within a
measure refer to these
staffDef declarations using their own @n attribute values. Therefore, the encoding order of staves within a measure does not have to mimic the order of the
staffDef elements with
In addition to the parameters inherited from
scoreDef, the following attributes are important for
Records the direction of octave displacement to be applied to the clef.
A staff with a tenor clef is encoded as in the following example:
In the case of transposing instruments, the key-related attributes described above may be used to override the written key expressed in the
scoreDef element. As a basic principle, MEI always captures written pitches, so the @trans.diat and @trans.semi attributes may be used to indicate the number of diatonic steps and semitones to calculate sounded pitch from written pitch. The piccolo and E♭ clarinet staves in the example below utilize these attributes:
There are a number of additional elements that can be used as children of
staffDef in order to describe additional features of the staff, such as the color of a clef or a key signature added in a different hand. These elements include:
(meter signature group) – Used to capture alternating, interchanging, and mixed meter
With the exception of
label, these elements may also occur within the flow of musical events captured in a
layer, since they are members of
model.eventLike. In the layer context they function as milestones and affect all following content assigned to the layer (even in subsequent measures) until their information is again overridden either by the same element bearing different information or a
scoreDef. In this context, it is also possible to combine them with the elements described in chapters
Critical Apparatus and
Editorial Markup of these Guidelines.
Such flexibility as this may require close inspection of an encoding to retrieve the correct definitions for a given staff. As a general rule, the closest preceding and most specific element provides this information: For example, a
keySig in the preceding measure is more relevant than a
staffDef at the beginning of the section, which is more relevant than a
scoreDef at the beginning of the score. However, a section-specific
scoreDef that provides only information about the meter does not override the more specific information about key signature gathered from a
staffDef for a transposing instrument.
staffDef may contain a number of
layerDef elements, which may be used to establish default values for the distinct layers sharing one staff. MEI does not use the term ‘voice’ to describe these ‘musical threads’ because that term implies continuity across measure boundaries. Given the sometimes arbitrary relationships between these threads from measure to measure as well as across staves, MEI uses the more neutral term ‘layer’.
4.2.3. Redefinition of Score Parameters
Sometimes it is necessary to provide the parameters of a score or a staff with new values. For example. a score may change keys, gain or lose staves, use different layout settings at any point, etc. Likewise, a staff may change its clef, gain or lose layers, or become invisible, and so on. To accommodate these circumstances, in CMN
staffDef is allowed to occur in the following locations:
within the description of staff groups; that is, in
within sections and endings; that is, inside
ending elements; and
between sections and endings; that is, directly within a
The possibility also exists to include
staffDef in staves and layers when the mei-all schema is in use; however, this practice is not recommended for the CMN repertoire.
4.2.4. Notes, Chords and Rests in CMN
Undoubtedly, the most important element for any music notation representation is the
note element, which is defined in section
Basic Music Events. This section describes the usage of
note in the CMN repertoire as well as CMN-specific additions to the basic definition in the shared module.
188.8.131.52.1. Basic Usage of Notes in CMN
In CMN, notes are determined by three basic parameters:
pitch name (using @pname)
octave (using @oct)
duration (using @dur)
A typical note, in this case a quarter note C4, is therefore encoded like so:
Because these attributes may not be required in all situations (such as @dur for the notes of a chord), processing software should anticipate retrieving the information that would have been provided by missing attributes from a preceding note or
chord parent in the same
layer. Only information from @pname, @oct and @dur attributes can be gathered in this fashion. No other attributes can be treated this way.
The default values for @pname and @oct conform to the Acoustical Society of America representation for pitch name; that is, the letters A - G, albeit in lower case, and the numbers 0 - 9.
The usual CMN-specific values for @dur are:
1: whole note
2: half note
4: quarter note
8: eighth note
16: sixteenth note
2048: 2048th note
Additionally, the following two values borrowed from mensural notation are allowed, as they sometimes also appear in CMN:
breve: double whole
long: quadruple whole
Please note that their mensural counterparts bear different names in order to clearly distinguish between repertoires.
Dotted durational values are accommodated by the @dots attribute, which records the number of written augmentation dots. Thus, a dotted quarter note is represented as in the following example:
184.108.40.206.2. Grace Notes
The CMN module adds two optional attributes, @grace and @grace.time, to
chord. The presence of the @grace attribute indicates a grace note or chord.
The encoding of the left-most example would look like this:
Grace notes are not counted when determining the measure’s conformance to the current time signature. Therefore, the @dur attribute records only the written rhythmic value of the grace note. The time necessary for the performance of grace notes can be unspecified, calculated based on taking time from other non-grace notes, or specified precisely using the @dur.ges attribute.
The values of @grace indicate from which note time is ‘borrowed’ to perform the grace note: The preceding note, in which case the value ‘unacc’ (unaccented) is used, or the following note, when the value ‘acc’ (accented) is appropriate. Technically, this value determines if the note following the grace will keep its original onset time or will be slightly delayed to allow the grace note itself to be accented. Sometimes it is not clear how to perform a grace; in these situations the value ‘unknown’ allows one to indicate a grace note while unambiguously stating that its performed duration remains unknown.
The @grace.time attribute is only to be used in combination with the @grace attribute. It records the amount of time (as a percentage of the written duration) that the grace note should ‘steal’ from the preceding note (when @grace=’unacc’) or the following note (when @grace=’acc’).
Multiple grace notes can be grouped within a
graceGrp element, which itself allows all values for @grace as explained above. The optional @attach attribute is used to record whether the grace note group is attached to the following event or to the preceding one.
Often we find multiple notes that are not sounding in succession but sounding simultaneously. These chords in MEI are basically defined as a container of notes that are stemmed together.
220.127.116.11.1. Chords in CMN
A chord is any set of pitches consisting of multiple notes that are to be played simultaneously and are usually grouped together visually with a single stem. In MEI the
chord element functions as a container for all participating notes. Also it features many attributes that are allowed for notes, e.g. usually all notes in a chord have a common duration, so it can be applied to the whole chord within it’s @dur attribute.
Some notational features like articulations or lyrics are connected to a whole chord instead of a single note. Therefore elements like
verse are also allowed as children of
chord elements. In the follwing example from Sergei Rachmaninoff’s Prelude in C-sharp minor, Op. 3, No. 2 all chords carry an accent.
18.104.22.168.2. Stem Modifications
The @stem.mod attribute accommodates various stem modifiers found in the CMN repertoire. These symbols are placed on a note or chord’s stem and generally indicate different types of tremolo and Sprechstimme. The following values are allowed:
1slash: 1 slash through stem
2slash: 2 slashes through stem
3slash: 3 slashes through stem
4slash: 4 slashes through stem
5slash: 5 slashes through stem
6slash: 6 slashes through stem
sprech: X placed on stem
z: Z placed on stem
The @stem.mod attibute is normally used in accordance with practices described in section
The CMN module makes the
att.stems.cmn attribute class available, which adds the optional @stem.with attribute to
chord. The attribute @stem.with allows for the indication of a stem that joins notes on adjacent staves.
The following code demonstrates one method of encoding the first chord in the last measure in the image above. The @stem.with attribute must occur on all the notes or chords attached to the cross-staff stem.
Alternatively, the encoder may choose to treat the notes in the lower staff as logically belonging to the top staff and to ‘displace’ them using the @staff attribute on
note. Some use cases, however, may require filling the time that those notes would normally occupy using the
space element described in section
Event Spacing. Using this mechanism, the example above could also be encoded like so:
The choice between these two methods of representing material that crosses staves is often software-dependent.
The @dur attribute on
rest captures the written duration of the rest and allows the same values as on
chord. The CMN module also makes three more elements available for special forms of rest:
The @cutout attribute provides for the description of the rendition of the
mRest. If @cutout is set to ‘cutout’ (the only value allowed), then the complete staff including the staff lines will not be rendered for this measure.
It is a semantic error to mix an
mRest with other events in the same
layer. However, other ‘control events’, such as
fermata, may be used at the same time as
22.214.171.124.2. Multiple-Measure Rests
multiRest (multiple measure rest) element is used to encode multiple measures of rest. It is commonly used in performer parts, but due to the problem of synchronicity with other staves, it is never found in scores. A numeric value, stored in the @num attribute, indicates the number of resting measures. The older visual forms displayed below (often callled Kirchenpausen) are not captured by
multiRest, but may be created by rendering software. You may force modern block rests by using the @block attribute.
126.96.36.199.3. Empty Measures
mSpace (measure space) element is closely related to the
mRest elements. It is used to explicitly indicate that a layer has no content but that no information is missing from the encoding.
4.2.5. Timestamps and Durations
MEI offers multiple ways of defining onsets and offsets of timed musical events such as notes and slurs. The most common and most musician-friendly approach to this is through the use of a combination of the attributes @tstamp and @dur, which are made available by the attribute classes
att.timestamp.logical (inherited by
att.timestamp2.logical, both from the shared module.
The timestamp (@tstamp) of a musical event is calculated in relation to the meter of the current measure and resembles the so-called ‘beat’ position. In a common time measure with four quarter notes, the timestamp of each quarter equals its beat position in the measure: The first quarter has a timestamp of 1, the second has a timestamp of 2, and so on. MEI defines the value of @tstamp as a real number; the second eighth note position in a measure would thus be represented by the value of “1.5”. The range of possible values is defined as starting with zero and ending with the number of metrical units in a measure (the ‘numerator’ in a time signature) + 1. This allows the capture of all graphical positions starting from the left barline (‘0’) and ending with the right barline of the measure (‘5’, in the case of 4/4 time).
For ‘spanning’ elements like slurs, which are members of the
model.controlEventLike class, it is often more intuitive to record two timestamps – one for the onset of the event and one for its termination. Because the termination of the event may be in a succeeding measure, the second timestamp (@tstamp2) has a slightly different datatype than the one marking the initiation of the event. Its datatype is constrained to values following the formula “xm + y”, where x is the number of full measures that this particular feature lasts (or the number of bar lines crossed) and y is the timestamp in the target measure where the feature ends. The timestamp is expressed using the same logic as described above. For example, a value of “0m+3” in 4/4 time indicates that the element bearing this attribute, a slur for example, ends on beat 3 of the same measure where it started. A value of “1m+1.5” would indicate an end on the second eighth note of the following measure. In 6/8 time, the value “2m+3” means that the feature ends two measures later on the third eighth note.
4.3. Advanced CMN Features
Over time, in addition to the basic features of note, chord, and rest, many other symbols have been added to CMN. The following section describes some of these symbols and introduces their handling in MEI.
A very common feature of music from the CMN repertoire is the beaming of eighth or shorter notes. MEI provides two elements for the explicit encoding of features joined by beams.
(beam span) – Alternative element for explicitly encoding beams, particularly those which
extend across bar lines.
Use of the
beam element is straightforward. The beamed notes, rests, or chords are simply enclosed by the
Whereas in music notation every note value shorter than an eighth adds another beam (sometimes referred to as ‘secondary beams’), in MEI only one beam element is used, no matter the durations of the contained notes. The visual rendition of a set of beamed notes is presumed to be handled by rendering processes.
From the 19th century onwards, it became quite common to break secondary beams to increase readability of longer beamed passages. The optional @breaksec attribute on
chords under the beam may be used to encode the breaking of secondary beams after the note or chord bearing the attribute. The value of @breaksec indicates the number of continuous beams. For example:
In the music of the second half of the 20th century, it is quite common to indicate acceleration or deceleration using converging (feathered) beams as in the image below:
The encoding of such a beam is accomplished using the @form attribute of the beam, which allows the following values:
acc: Beams gradually diverge.
rit: Beams gradually converge (into one).
mixed: Beams diverge and converge arbitrarily.
norm: The beam is rendered as usual (default).
The duration of notes, rests, or chords under a beam which carries the @form attribute with a value of ‘acc’, ‘rit’, or ‘mixed’ must be treated specially. The first and last contained elements must specify a duration which matches the number of beams displayed at the point of these events. In the case of a ‘mixed’ beam, each event at the point of change in the number of secondary beams must carry a @dur attribute. Beams like this may be encoded thusly:
Beams that connect events on different staves may be encoded in two different ways. First, a single-layer approach may be taken that treats the events lying under the beam as logically belonging to the same layer as the initial event but visually ‘displaced’ to an adjacent staff. In the example above from Moritz Moszkowski’s12 Pianoforte Studies for the left hand, Op. 92, MoszWV 117 this method makes even from a semantic perspective perfect sense. It can be achieved with an additional @staff attribute value that contradicts the ‘normal’ staff placement indicated by the @n attribute of their ancestor
In other contexts however, a staff-by-staff methodology may be employed in which the notes are encoded according to the staff on which they appear. This encoding style requires that each
beam element account for the total time encompassed by the beam; that is, each
beam must use one or more
space elements to account for the time occupied by notes on the opposing staff. For example, the time used by the first two notes of the beam must be represented on staff number 1 and the time taken by the last two notes of the beam must be filled on staff number 2.
Downstream processing needs are the determining factor in the choice between the two alternative encoding methods.
Due to the potential problem of overlapping hierarchies, the
beam element only allows the encoding of beams that do not cross barlines. When beams cross barlines, the use of the
beamSpan element is required. Unlike
beamSpan element does not contain the beamed notes as its children. Instead, it references the @xml:id values of all affected notes in its @plist attribute and denotes the initial and terminal notes of the beam using @startid and @endid attributes. This configuration allows beams to cross measure boundaries. The following example from Erwin Schulhoff’sViolin Sonata demonstrates a typical example of such hierarchy-crossing beams:
In addition to the explicit encoding of beams accommodated by the
beamSpan elements and the @beam attribute, MEI allows for specification of default beaming behavior using the following attributes on
beam.group: Provides an example of how automated beaming (including secondary beams) is to be performed.
beam.rests: Indicates whether automatically-drawn beams should include rests shorter than a quarter note duration.
The @beam.group attribute can be used to set a default beaming pattern to be used when no beaming is indicated at the layer level. It must contain a comma-separated list of time values that add up to a measure in the current meter, e.g., ‘4,4,4,4’ in 4/4 time indicates that each quarter note worth of shorter notes should be beamed together. Parentheses can be used to indicate sub-groupings of secondary beams. For example, ‘(4.,4.,4.)’ in 9/8 meter indicates one primary beam per measure with secondary beams broken at each dotted quarter duration, while ‘(4,4),(4,4)’ in 4/4 will result in a measure of 16th notes being rendered with a primary beam covering all the notes and secondary beams for each group of four 16th notes.
The @beam.group attribute is available on
layerDef elements, making it possible to set different beaming patterns for each of these. Also, the beaming pattern can be changed anywhere score parameters may be changed, for example, at the start of sections. This beaming “directive” can be overridden by using
beamSpan, or @beam attributes as described above. If none of these beaming specifications is used, then no beaming is implied. Default beaming can be explicitly ‘turned off’ by setting @beam.group to an empty string.
4.3.2. Ties, Slurs and Phrase Marks
One of the most specific features of CMN is the use of ‘curved lines’ which connect notes. These lines are used to indicate various musical features, depending on their context.
A tie is a curved line connecting two notes of the same pitch. The purpose of a tie is to join the durations of both notes, so that the first note sounds for the combined duration. In other words, there is only one onset for both notes.
In MEI, ties can be encoded in different ways, depending on the level of detail that the encoder wants to preserve. The simplest solution is to use the @tie attribute found on
This attribute allows three values:
i (initial): Marks the start of a tie
m (medial): Marks a participant in a tie other than the first or last
t (terminal): Marks the end of a tie
The scope of the @tie attribute is the musical
layer; that is, a tie started in one layer may only be ended by a subsequent musical event with a @tie attribute with an m or t value in the same layer. The tie-terminating event may lie in the following measure.
When @tie is used on chords, it functions as a shorthand indication for multiple tie markings; that is, a separate tie is drawn for every pitch in the chord that remains unchanged in the succeeding chord.
This is equivalent to the following, more verbose version:
A slur is a curved line that connects a group of notes of different pitch. It normally indicates that an instrument-specific performance technique should be applied to the affected notes. For example, in notation for winds, the notes should be played in one breath, while a single bow is indicated for string instruments.
In MEI, slurs may be encoded in a similar way to ties:
chord bear a @slur attribute that allows the commencement or ending of a slur at this element. The allowed values, however, are slightly different: The i, m or t are followed by a single digit in the range 1 to 6, as in the following example:
The reason for this difference is that slurs, unlike ties, may overlap, so that a second slur may start while the first slur is still ongoing. The digit indicates the level of nesting of slurs on the note; ‘1’ indicates no nesting, while ‘2’ indicates the existence of 2 slurs in which this note participates, and so on. In the example below, the second and third quarter notes lie under 2 slurs. The second note is covered by the slur that begins on the preceding note and by the one that it starts. The third note is affected by the slur that begins on note one and by the one that starts on note two.
To support analytical operations, @slur may take on more than one value. For example, the example above may be more explicitly encoded as:
In this encoding, the notes in the beamed group are marked as participating in two slurs – one connecting just the beamed notes and one connecting the first and last notes of the layer. In ‘nested’ slurs like this, the function of the slurs is usually different. Here, the slur connecting the 8th notes indicates legato performance, while the longer slur functions as a phrase mark.
While ties are not normally allowed to cross layers or staves, slurs may. The following example demonstrates how cross-staff slurs may be encoded using the @slur attribute:
Slurs and ties that cross system or page breaks are often split into two separate symbols for rendering. One slur or tie ends at the last barline, another one starts at the beginning of the new system. MEI expects this to be the default rendering behaviour, so that in situations like these, the regular @tie or @slur attributes are sufficient to describe both curved lines resulting from the split.
Sometimes, however, one of these two symbols is missing in the document, or the encoder wants to provide additional (often visual) information about the slur or tie. In these cases, using an attribute is not an adequate solution. Therefore, MEI offers dedicated
slur elements. A third element,
phrase, is used to identify a unified melodic idea (in German: Phrasierungsbogen), whereas the
slur element is used as a generic element for all curved lines (in German: Bogensetzung) except ties. All three elements have nearly identical models.
Another reason for using elements instead of attributes for ties, slurs, and phrase marks is that only elements may be combined with the functionality provided in chapters
Editorial Markup and
Critical Apparatus of these Guidelines.
Although these elements are allowed within a
layer to accommodate unmeasured notation, by convention in CMN they are normally placed inside
measure, after the encoding of staves, alongside other so-called ‘control events’.
Obviously, to be complete the slur in the above example needs to be ‘attached’ to the notes somehow. The ‘vertical assignment’ can be indicated for the example above using the @staff and @layer attributes like so:
For the ‘horizontal assignment’, the encoder may choose between two different mechanisms. The first uses two timestamp attributes as described in section
Timestamps and Durations. The start and end points of the slur may be indicated thusly:
By using @tstamp and @tstamp2 attributes, the encoder denotes a rather loose connection – the slur (or tie) is attached to a certain position in the measure, not to a specific note or chord. If the encoder wants to specify a close connection to a particular event, the @startid and @endid attributes may be used instead. Here, the @xml:ids of the first and last note of the slur are referenced. This mechanism also allows the crossing of layers and staves.
For human readability, it is recommended to encode
phrase features in the
measure where they begin; that is, in the measure that holds the element referenced by @startid. On the other hand, for machine processability, it may be desirable to place
phrase elements in the measure where they end or even in the last measure regardless of their beginning and ending points in the music. This last option makes all references contained within these elements ‘back references’. Back references are necessary when using processing software that treats the encoded file as a stream; that is, programs that process the file without creating an in-memory representation of its contents.
When using the
phrase elements, the curvature of the line may be described using the @curvedir, @bulge and @bezier attributes. Whereas the first attribute allows only specification of the slur’s vertical placement, the others give increasingly more precise control of the curve.
If the encoder wishes to draw attention to the appearance of a slur or tie in a given source, the @facs attribute may be used instead of (or in addition to) the curve description attributes to point to a graphic image or a zone within an image (see
4.3.3. Dynamics in CMN
Common Music Notation provides two different methodologies for expressing the volume of a note, phrase, section, etc. The first is a verbal instruction providing such information in human language, possibly in an abbreviated form. An example is the word piano, indicating a quiet volume, often abbreviated as p. In MEI, verbal instructions like this are encoded using the
dynam element from the Shared module (see chapter
Shared Concepts in MEI):
dynam elements, like
slur and other elements belonging to the
model.controlEventLike class, are encoded at the end of the
measure to which they belong. This requires
dynam to be assigned to a certain
staff using the @staff attribute, whose value refers to the target element’s @n attribute. In the absence of other information, all layers within the staff are assumed to have the same dynamic marking.
However, when the layers of a staff have different dynamic indications, the @layer attribute may be used to associate a dynamic marking with a particular layer:
A suitable MIDI value may be assigned to a dynamic marking using the @val attribute:
The location of a dynamic marking in relation to a staff may be specified using the @place attribute, which may be given as above, within, or below the staff:
Dynamics must also be associated with a particular time point in a measure, using the @tstamp, or with a particular event, using the @startid attribute. Linking a control event with measures and events is discussed in section
Timestamps and Durations:
Dynamics which do not have an explicit endpoint are often referred to as ‘instantaneous’. On the other hand, some dynamic directions indicate a continuous change that must have a defined end point. It is possible to specify the logical scope of continuous dynamic marks using the attributes @tstamp2, @dur, @dur.ges, or @endid. Additionally a corresponding ending value for MIDI output may be given in the @val2 attribute.
To capture the fact that the crescendo in the example above continue until the first beat of the next measure, they may be marked:
Any combination of @tstamp, @startid, @tstamp2, and @endid attributes may be used to define the scope of a dynamic, although the @tstamp and @tstamp2 or the @startid and @endid combinations are the most logical combinations. For example, the following alternatives are all possibilities for encoding up a crescendo. The choice of attributes is often task or processor dependent.
All musical elements affected by the
dynam may be explicitly specified using the @plist attribute, which contains @xml:id attribute value references:
It is recommended that the list of references in @plist include all participants in the dynamic marking, including the first and last notes as in the preceding example, even though they are duplicated by @startid and @endid attributes.
In addition to verbal instructions, Common Music Notation uses graphical symbols to indicate ‘continuous’ dynamics. These crescendo and decrescendo (or diminuendo) symbols are encoded in MEI using the
hairpin element. It also is a member of the
model.controlEventLike class, which means it too is used just before the close of a
measure element, following the encoding of all staves. The required attribute @form specifies the direction of the symbol by taking one of two possible values: cres (growing louder) or dim (getting softer).
Marking the logical extent of hairpins is possible using the same attributes as for
The following example from Béla Bartók’sMikrokosmos, Sz.107 shows a diminuendo between two staves that begins on the first beat (in the current measure) and ends on the first one in the penultimate measure. The duration is highlighted with a dashed line, which can be indicated with the @extender attribute.
Tuplets indicate a localized change of meter; that is, a given duration in the regular meter is divided between a group of notes with irregular (according to the current meter) rhythmic values. The most common tuplet is a so-called ‘triplet’, in which three notes take the time normally occupied by two.
The relation of the tuplet to the underlying meter is specified using the @num and @numbase attributes, where @num specifies the number of replacing notes and @numbase specifies the number of notes of the same duration to be replaced. For example, when three eighth notes replace one quarter note in common time, @num takes a value of “3”, whereas @numbase reads “2”, because a quarter note in common time is normally divided into two eighths. When three quarters replace two in the same meter, @numbase also reads “2”. The combination of these attributes may be read as “3 in the time of 2” in either case.
The duration of the entire tuplet may be encoded using the usual ‘power of 2’ values, e.g., 1, 2, 4, etc., in the @dur attribute if necessary.
Tuplets are often highlighted using brackets above or below the affected notes. The presence and position of these brackets can be encoded using the @bracket.place (above / below) and @bracket.visible (true / false) attributes.
Usually, however, tuplets are rendered with a bracket (@bracket.visible=”true”) and a single number (@num.format=”count” and @num.visible=”true”), as seen in the example above. However, the number-to-numbase ratio may be provided in addition to, or in some cases as a replacement for, the bracket. The @num.format attribute indicates whether a plain number (the value of @num) or a ratio (comprised of @num and @numbase, e.g., “3:2”) should be displayed and @num.visible indicates the general presence of such a number.
Further visual control comes with the @num.place and @bracket.place attributes, that allow specific placement of the number and the bracket “above” or “below” the staff.
In addition to
tuplet may contain other elements, such as
space, to match the content of a source document or an intended rendering. In particular, the
beam element is allowed so that custom beaming may be indicated, e.g., a septuplet may be divided into a group of three plus a group of four notes.
tuplet element may also be used for repetition of the same pitch; that is, a single note or chord may be the only content of the tuplet. In some cases, optical music recognition software may treat these instances as bowed tremolandi due to the knowledge of the complete semantics of the notation at the time of recognition. However, marking these as tuplets is the recommended practice.
In some situations, a tuplet is made up of events in different measures. As this raises the issue of non-concurrent hierarchies, it is not possible to encode such situations with the
tuplet element described above. Therefore, MEI offers the
tupletSpan element, which is member of the
model.controlEventLike class. It is nested inside of
measure, following all the measure’s
staff children. It uses the same attributes as
tuplet to describe tuplets, but instead of nesting all affected notes inside itself, it references the @xml:id values of all affected notes in its @plist attribute and the initial and terminal notes of the tuplet using @startid and @endid attributes. This configuration allows tuplets to cross beams or measure boundaries. The following example demonstrates a typical example of such hierarchy-crossing tuplets:
4.3.5. Articulation and Performance Instructions in CMN
This section introduces elements and attributes which may hold CMN-specific performance instructions. The functionality described herein is related to the @artic attribute and
artic element introduced in
Shared Concepts in MEI. The following elements are relevant in this context:
An indication placed over a note or rest to indicate that it should be held longer than
its written value. May also occur over a bar line to indicate the end of a phrase or section.
Sometimes called a 'hold' or 'pause'.
An indication that a passage should be performed one or more octaves above or below its
188.8.131.52. Arpeggio and Glissando
In CMN, the notes of a chord are sometimes performed successively rather than simultaneously. This behavior, called arpeggiation, is normally indicated using a vertical wavy line preceding the chord. MEI offers the
arpeg element to describe arpeggios. This element is a member of the
model.controlEventLike.cmn class and, like other members of this class, uses the @staff, @layer and @tstamp or the @startid and @plist attributes to connect it to the affected chord.
For arpeggios that involve chords spanning multiple staves as a continuous arpeggio (instead of two separate arpeggios), the @plist attribute should be used to point to all affected
chord and single
note elements’ @xml:id attributes. Therefore, the use of the @plist attribute is sufficient in many cases, so that other attributes from above may be omitted.
The usual direction for the performance of an arpeggio is from lowest note to highest, but this is not always the case. The customary signal of an downward arpeggio is an arrowhead added to the bottom of the wavy line. The indication of the presence of an arrowhead and the direction of the arpeggio are handled separately, however. The @arrow attribute indicates the presence of an arrowhead in the arpeggiation sign, while the @order attribute records the preferred sequence of notes.
Béla Bartók uses a wavy line behind the chord to indicate a downward arpeggio. In such cases, the @ho attribute can be used to indicate the offset from the usual position.
The following examples illustrate various ways in which the arrow and order attributes may be employed. The default visual rendition and performance are assumed in the absence of both attributes, while the typical downward arpeggio is indicated by the presence of both attributes. The last two possibilities occur less frequently, but are sometimes appropriate: The presence of the arrow attribute without the order attribute may be used in those cases where the arrowhead is redundant but is added to the symbol for the sake of consistency or when the direction of successive arpeggios changes frequently. The last possibility, an order attribute without an arrow attribute, is ambiguous; however, it can be used as an encoding shortcut since a downward arpeggio must have a visual indication of its direction to distinguish it from the upward arpeggio; therefore, the presence of the arrowhead can be implied.
A third, and somewhat counter-intuitive, value for @order, “nonarp”, indicates that no arpeggio shall be performed. Normally rendered as a bracket instead of a wavy line, this form of arpeggio is used to indicate a non-arpeggiated chord intervening in a sequence of arpeggiated ones. This is common in music for the harp, where arpeggiation is the usual method of performing chords and deviation from the norm must be explicitly indicated.
Whereas an arpeggio ‘staggers’ the onset times of the notes of a chord, a glissando denotes a situation where the pitch ‘slides’ from one note to another. It makes no difference whether this slide produces distinct intermediate pitches (as on the piano) or not (as on the trombone), though the latter is sometimes referred to as portamento. The visual appearance of a glissando, which MEI encodes as
gliss, is normally a line connecting two notes in the glissando.
gliss element is a member of the
model.controlEventLike class and therefore, like other control events, it occurs inside a measure after the staves and uses its @staff, @layer, @tstamp, @tstamp2, @startid and @endid attributes to connect it to the affected notes or chords. It is a semantic error not to specify a starting point attribute. The visual appearance of the indicating line may be recorded in the @line.form and @line.width attributes.
A bend is a variation in pitch (often microtonal) upwards or downwards during the course of a note. Typically, the performer attacks the note at ‘true’ pitch, changes the intonation, then returns to true pitch. The
bend element can also be used for so-called scoop, plop, falloff, and doit performance effects. It should not be used for laissez vibrer (l.v.) indications. As with other elements in the
model.controlEventLike class, the starting point of the bend may be indicated by either a @tstamp, @tstamp.ges, @tstamp.real or @startid attribute. It is a semantic error not to specify a starting attribute.
CMN has two slightly different concepts which are both called tremolo. The first is a rapid repetition of a single pitch or chord, whereas the second is a rapid alternation between two different notes or chords. In addition, either species of tremolo may be measured or unmeasured. A measured tremolo is an abbreviation for written-out notation; that is, the tremolo is intended to be perceived as notes with distinct rhythmic values. On the other hand, in an unmeasured tremolo no specific number of alternations is intended.
For the repetition of a single note or chord, MEI offers the
bTrem (bowed tremolo) element, which is a member of the
model.eventLike.cmn class, meaning it is encoded following the normal course of musical events within a
layer. It holds exactly one
chord element that is to be repeated.
The @unitdur attribute value indicates the exact note values in an aural rendition of a measured tremolo, i.e., quarters, 8ths, and so on. The @stem.mod attribute must also be explicity set on the child
chord element for a complete visual representation. The example above shows a short excerpt from the second movement of Franz Schubert’sString Quartet in G major, D. 887.
However, the number of slashes present on the note may disagree with the number of slashes that should be present according to the @unitdur attribute, especially in music manuscripts.
Note that within beams the number of slashes should be adjusted anyway.
bTrem element can be used as shorthand for a tuplet consisting of repetitions of a single note or chord. This kind of markup may be the result of an optical music recognition process in which complete semantics cannot be determined a priori. When used this way, the @num attribute on
bTrem can record a number to be rendered along with the pseudo-tuplet. In spite of this capability, the
tuplet element is preferred. This makes the following examples’ visual appearance equal, but not necessarily their semantics.
In the case of alternating pitches, MEI offers the
fTrem (fingered tremolo) element. While it mostly behaves the same as
bTrem, a fingered tremolo requires exactly two child elements, either being a
chord. The @unitdur attribute value indicates the exact note values in an aural rendition of a measured tremolo, i.e., 4ths, 8ths, 16ths, etc. The number of beams present in the source is captured by the @beams attribute.
bTrem, here the number of beams present may disagree with the rhythmic value indicated by the @unitdur attribute, especially in manuscript sources. The number of so-called “floating” beams, which are not attached to stems, may be encoded in the @beams.float attribute.
A very common feature of music notation from the CMN period is the so-called ‘fermata’ (or ‘corona’ in Italian). It is usually written as a dot above or below an arc. It may stand above or below the staff it affects with its ‘open’ side usually facing towards the staff. A fermata indicates that a related note or rest should be held longer than its written duration would normally require. Sometimes, a fermata occurs over or under a barline to indicate a pause or even the end of a phrase or section.
In MEI, fermatas may be encoded using an attribute on elements like
rest. This attribute allows placement of a fermata above or below the element to which it’s attached.
However, if there is further (visual) information about the fermata that should be addressed in the encoding, MEI offers the
fermata element. This element, which is a member of the
model.controlEventLike.cmn class and therefore requires the use of such attributes as @staff, @layer, @tstamp and @startid, allows specification of the orientation of the fermata using its @form attribute. In addition, the @shape attribute may be used to indicate whether the fermata is rendered as the common semicircle
(“curved”), a semisquare
(“square”), or a triangle
(“angular”). If the fermata should be rendered using some other symbol, a user-defined symbol may be referred to using an @altsym attribute or the @glyph.name and @glyph.num attributes respectively.
184.108.40.206. Octave Shift
An indication that a passage should be performed one or more octaves above or below its written pitch is represented by the
Its @dis and @dis.place attributes record the amount and direction of displacement, respectively. The @lform attribute captures the appearance of the continuation line associated with the octave displacement. The starting point of the octave displacement may be indicated by either a @tstamp, @tstamp.ges, @tstamp.real or @startid attribute, while the ending point may be recorded by either a @tstamp2, @dur, @dur.ges or @endid attribute. It is a semantic error not to specify one starting-type attribute and one ending-type attribute.
4.3.6. Instrument-specific Symbols in CMN
CMN contains a number of symbols which are closely related to a specific instrument. MEI offers elements for three of these symbols, namely breath marks, harp pedal diagrams, and piano pedals.
220.127.116.11. Breath Marks
A breath mark indicates a point at which the performer of a wind instrument or singer may breathe. It is sometimes also used to indicate a short pause or break for instruments not requiring breath, which allows it to also serve as a guide to phrasing. In MEI, breath marks are encoded using the
breath element, which is a member of
model.controlEventLike.cmn. It is a semantic error not to specify a starting point attribute.
The usual sign for the breath mark is a comma; however, other visual forms of the breath mark may be indicated using the @altsym attribute (see chapter
User-defined Symbols for further details).
18.104.22.168. Harp Pedals
Modern harps have seven pedals which allow adjustment of their strings to different pitches. The settings for these pedals occur at the beginning of the harp notation and/or whenever it is necessary to change the harp’s tuning. These settings may be rendered using letter pitches (in the order of the pedals from left to right) or in a diagrammatic fashion, such as the form invented by Carlos Salzedo.
The musical intention of the element is described using the @c, @d, @e, @f, @g, @a and @b attributes, which affect the corresponding strings of the harp. All of these attributes may take the values “f” (flat), “s” (sharp) or “n” (natural), where “n” is the default value, which is assumed when one of these attributes is not specified.
In the first diagram of the preceding example, the B, and E pedals are in the flat position, while the C pedal is in sharp position. The other, non-specified pedals are in the natural position.
22.214.171.124. Piano Pedal
Music for piano also often includes indications of the use of pedals. In MEI, these symbols are encoded using the
pedal element. As a member of the
model.controlEventLike.cmn class, it is located within
measure and refers to a staff, layer and timestamp using the @staff, @layer and @tstamp attributes. Alternatively, the @startid attribute may be used to identify a
chord to which the mark should be assigned.
The meaning of the mark is captured using the @dir attribute, which provides the following values:
down: depress the pedal
up: release the pedal
bounce: release, then immediately depress the pedal again
half: depress the pedal half way
To specify the pedal, that has to be used, the @func attribute allows the following values:
sustain: The sustain pedal, also referred to as the “damper” pedal, allows the piano strings to vibrate sympathetically with the struck strings. It is the right-most and the most frequently used pedal on modern pianos. (Often marked with:
soft: The soft pedal, sometimes called the “una corda”, “piano”, or “half-blow” pedal, reduces the volume and modifies the timbre of the piano. On the modern piano, it is the left-most pedal.
sostenuto: The sostenuto or tone-sustaining pedal allows notes already undamped to continue to ring while other notes are damped normally; that is, on their release by the fingers. This is usually the center pedal of the modern piano. (Often marked with:
silent The silent or practice pedal mutes the volume of the piano so that one may practice quietly. It is sometimes a replacement for the sostenuto pedal, especially on an upright or vertical instrument.
A common feature for keyboard music is fingering, indicating the finger, which should be used to play a single note. Basic fingering can be encoded in MEI using the
fing element, which is a member of the
model.model.fingeringLike class, and thus part of the
The term ossia, Italian for “or”, denotes an alternative for a certain passage which is provided by the composer without any preference of one alternative over another. An ossia often provides a simpler (easier to perform) version of the original content. Another frequent use case for ossia is the provision of indications about performance practice, such as an alternative version with ornamentation written out in full. In all cases, it is up to the performer to choose between the alternatives.
Most often an ossia is rendered above the main staff on a reduced-size staff. Sometimes, however, the alternate material occurs on the same staff as the primary text, but in a separate layer. In this case, the alternative material is usually rendered in small-sized notation on the normal-sized staff. For both situations, MEI offers the
ossia element, which may be nested either inside
measure to reflect an ossia on a separate staff, or inside
staff to reflect an inline ossia in a separate layer. The following example demonstrates an ossia on a separate staff:
The example above demonstrates that only one of the two
staff elements within
ossia has an @n attribute. This mechanism allows one to distinguish between the “regular” and the “alternative” content: The one bearing the @n attribute goes in line with the preceding measure’s staff, the other one is printed in reduced size above. In this case, the vertical order of staves follows document order: The top-most staff is encoded as the first child, the lowest comes last. In combination with the presence of the @n attribute, this allows the capture of multiple simultaneous ossia staves.
All staves within
ossia, even the alternative ones without a direct reference, obey the definitions of the associated
staffDef, which can be derived from the value of the @n attribute. Alternatively, a separate
staffDef may be given at the beginning of the contained
In case of an inline ossia, the whole setup of elements moves down one step in the hierarchy, as seen in the following example:
4.3.8. Directives and Rehearsal marks
In CMN scores, there is often a large number of natural language instructions. Some of them concern the loudness and the speed of the performance, in which case MEI offers the elements
dynam (described at
Dynamics in CMN) and
tempo. In other cases, however, they provide other instructions for the performer. Instead of providing separate elements for all possible types of such directions, MEI offers the generic
dir element. Although this element is not CMN specific (it is defined in
Shared Concepts in MEI), it is frequently used in this repertoire.
126.96.36.199. Tempo changes and other directives
A tempo or character indication is often provided above the topmost staff of the first measure of a score, movement, or section. This indication, such as “Allegro moderato” or “Andante maestoso”, may be regarded as a label. Though it is possible to label the movement, etc. using a @label attribute attached to the enclosing structural entity (that is, on
section), it is often required to capture the exact position, spelling, or other features of the label as found in the underlying source material. In these cases, an element is necessary.
Labels which address the tempo at which the music should be performed should be encoded using the
tempo element, which is a specialized form of
tempo is a member of the
model.controlEventLike class and as such occurs as a child of
measure, following all
staff children. Its @staff, @layer and @tstamp attributes are used to ensure correct semantic positioning, and @place indicates a visual position with respect to the staff.
188.8.131.52. Rehearsal marks
Rehearsal marks are another specialized kind of directive. Consisting of letters, numbers, or a combination of both, rehearsal marks are used in scores and corresponding performer parts to identify convenient points to restart rehearsal after breaks or interruptions. For this reason, they are often visually emphasized by placing them within a square or circle. In MEI, they are encoded using the
reh element, which holds the textual content of the rehearsal mark. It is a member of the
model.controlEventLike.cmn class. The visual rendition of the rehearsal mark, including the surrounding shape, may be captured using the
rend element described in chapter
The following detail from an edition of Hector Berlioz’ Symphonie Fantastique shows a typical example:
As rehearsal marks usually are placed at the beginning of a measure the @tstamp attribute may be omitted. To place it anywhere else the @startid, @tstamp or even @ho attributes could be used.
The following example demonstrates how rehearsal marks often apply to more than one staff. In this instance, the rehearsal mark is placed above staff 1 and below staves 7 and 11.
4.3.9. Repetition in CMN
Repetition is a characteristic feature of music. Many musical forms rely on repetition (sometimes with modification) of distinct sections of the music. Repetition in this sense can be thought of as ‘structural’. At the same time, composers and engravers of music often use local symbols for repeating smaller portions of music instead of writing them in full more than once. In this case, the repetition is better defined as a species of abbreviation.
In addition to repetition at the section level, CMN includes a number of different symbols for measure-level repetitions. Many of these symbols are found in manuscripts and may be regarded as personal conventions of their respective authors. Some signs, however, have been widely adopted. For example, it is common to indicate the repetition of a single beat or an entire measure with one or more diagonal lines, sometimes with dots at the upper left and lower right, much like a percent sign. The illustration below contains the most common signs:
In general, MEI places primary emphasis on the capture of the semantic meaning of symbols, not their visual rendition. In this case, the focus is on the material being repeated, for example, a beat, a measure, a 2-measure fragment, etc. The following elements are provided for this purpose:
beatRpt element is used to represent a single repeated beat. Its visual rendition can be recorded using the @slash attribute. This attribute indicates the number of slashes required to render the appropriate repeat symbol, which, as demonstrated in the preceding figure, depends on the rhythmic content of the beat being repeated. When a beat that consists of a single note or chord is repeated, the repetition sign is typically rendered as a single thick, slanting slash; therefore, the value ‘1’ should be used. The following values should be used when the beat is divided into even notes: 4ths or 8ths=1, 16ths=2, 32nds=3, 64ths=4, 128ths=5. When the beat is comprised of mixed duration values, the symbol is always rendered as 2 slashes and 2 dots.
In addition to its indication of a repeated beat, the beatRpt element is sometimes used in popular music notation, especially in guitar or percussion parts, to indicate a repeated rhythmic pattern. The
beatRpt element can be used, but when these parts require durations longer or shorter than a beat, note elements with appropriately-shaped note heads should be employed instead.
mRpt element is available for repetition of an entire measure. Like
mRest, it must be the sole child of
layer, no other events should be used. The @n attribute of
mRpt should not be used to record the number displayed above the measure in the figure below. Instead, the numbering of repetitions of the written-out measure can be enabled using the @multi.number attribute available on the
halfmRpt element represents the incorrect, but frequently found, use of the measure repeat (or similar) sign to indicate repetition of half of a measure. This practice mostly occurs in hand-written notation and usually involves the repetition of the second half of a measure in duple time. This element is necessary because the function of the symbol, not the visual symbol itself, is of primary importance. The following example from the beginning of Beethoven’s Waldstein sonata illustrates such usage:
As seen in the example above, it is possible to continuously repeat half measures, even across barlines.
multiRpt elements (like the
multiRest element) never occur in scores, only in performer parts, where it is often necessary to abbreviate the notation due to page size limitations.
mRpt2 element represents repetition of a 2-measure fragment, while
multiRpt is for repetition of fragments longer than two measures. In modern publishing practice, repeats of more than two measures are written out using repeat signs. This element is provided, however, for handling non-standard practices often found in manuscripts. The @num attribute on
multiRpt records the number of preceding measures to be repeated.
All elements described above allow for association of the sign with a symbol in a digital facsimile (via the @facs attribute) and with a user-defined symbol (using @altsym). See
User-defined Symbols for further details. In addition, the @expand attribute is available on the foregoing elements to inform a rendering process whether to use the repeat symbol or the full content represented by it. A value of “true” indicates that the content should be displayed, while a “false” value means to show only the repeat symbol.
4.4. Common Music Notation Ornaments
This module includes elements and attributes for the encoding of ornaments typical of ‘Common Music Notation’ (CMN). Ornaments are formulae of embellishment that can be realized by adding supplementary notes to one or more notes of the melody. In written form, these are usually expressed as symbols written above or below a note, though some have a more complex written expression, such as those that involve multiple notes and/or include grace notes.
These symbols may have different resolutions depending on a large number of factors, such as historical context, national boundaries, composer, scribe, etc. The elements described here, therefore, are not bound to a specific symbol; they are, instead, meant to encode the encoder’s interpretation of a symbol and its position on the staff.
Nonetheless, in order to establish common ground, the guidelines suggest commonly accepted symbols and realizations for the ornaments supported by MEI.
The following sections will introduce each element in detail for all types of ornaments supported.
4.4.1. Encoding Common To All Ornaments
When encoding CMN, ornaments should be encoded within a
measure, following the
staff elements, and connected to events on the staff via attributes. The @startid attribute is used to refer to the @xml:id of the starting note. Additionally, if the ornament involves more than one events on the staff, the @endid attribute can be used to anchor the ornament to a concluding event.
The following example demonstrates the encoding of a mordent over a middle C:
Alternatively, the relationship of an ornament to a note can be expressed in terms of beats with the attribute @tstamp. If the ornament involves more than one event on the staff, the @tstamp2 attribute can be used to indicate the ending time stamp, as is explained in section
Timestamps and Durations. These methods may also be utilized simultaneously.
The following example shows the use of @tstamp for an ornament. Assuming that the following measure is in 2/2, the ornament (in this case, a mordent) is related to the note on the second beat.
The relationship between an ornament and the notes on staff must always be encoded. It is, in fact, a semantic error not to specify a starting event or time stamp for an ornament.
In their resolution, ornaments will involve auxiliary notes, which typically follow the key signature or the scale of the current key. When the ornament involves other chromatic auxiliaries, an accidental is expressed next to or above the ornament sign. The attributes @accidlower and @accidupper, available on all ornaments described in this chapter, can be used to record this accidental. The attribute values ‘upper’ and ‘lower’ indicate whether the accidental is associated with an upper or lower auxiliary note, not the position of the accidental sign.
184.108.40.206. Overriding Default Resolutions
The symbols and sounded resolutions suggested for each ornament in this chapter are to be considered defaults. Nevertheless, because of the great historical and geographical variance in the notation of ornaments, the encoder is given methods to override the default resolutions.
It is possible, for example, to specify in the
meiHead a new default sounded resolution for an ornament. As discussed in the section
Encoding Description, the element
encodingDesc holds a description (optional, but recommended) of the methods and editorial principles which govern the transcription or encoding of the source material. Let us take a trill as an example. The section regarding
Trills does not set a specific number of alternations between the principal and secondary notes; the encoder, however, may specify an exact number in the encoding description.
Alternatively, resolutions can be defined on a case-by-case basis by encoding a specific resolution using the
choice element. See the section
Special Cases below for an example of a specific resolution of a trill.
A mordent is an ornament that involves an auxiliary note a step above or below the principal note. The presence of a mordent is encoded with the
mordent element and its attributes:
Records the written accidental associated with an upper neighboring note.
It is recommended, but not required, to use the attribute @form to encode the typology of mordents. Two common types are supported: those mordents that involve a note lower than the principal note, and those that involve a note higher than the principal note.
The attribute @form accepts the following values:
upper: usually corresponding to the symbol:
. This mordent is commonly performed as the principal note, followed by its upper neighbor, with a return to the principal note.
lower: usually corresponding to the symbol:
. This mordent is commonly performed as the principal note, followed by its lower neighbor, with a return to the principal note.
The following example demonstrates the encoding of simple mordents:
Occasionally, mordents can be longer, employing five notes instead of three. The @long attribute can be used to identify mordents of this type. The following example shows the encoding of a long mordent:
Trills are a type of ornament that consists of a rapid alternation of a note with one a semitone or tone above. A trill is encoded with the
trill element and its attributes:
Records the written accidental associated with an upper neighboring note.
Trills in modern notation are usually expressed with the abbreviation “tr” above a note on the staff. Often the abbreviation is followed by a wavy line that indicates the length of the trill.
The following example demonstrates the encoding of simple trills:
It has been specified earlier that it is a semantic error not to encode a starting event or time stamp for an ornament. This starting point of a trill can be expressed with the @startid attribute and/or with the @tstamp attribute. Specifying the end point is not required, although the @tstamp2 or @endid attribute may be used to imply the use of a wavy line extender as shown in this example:
When giving an end point to trills, the @extender attribute should also be added, to indicate the presence or absence of a line extender. Notice, that the note referenced in @endid is not part of the trill itself, just like in glissandos.
Chromatic alterations of auxiliary notes are occasionally expressed on the staff using small notes enclosed in parentheses, as shown in the example below. However, the attribute @accidupper is still to be used to encode the alteration. Display of the auxiliary note in this ‘cautionary’ manner is left to down-stream rendering processes.
Some trills may be introduced by a turn or followed by an inverted turn leading to the next note (see Le garzantine, Musica 2003, p. 911). In such cases, the trill is encoded as in previous examples and associated with the principal note. Starting or concluding turns are notated on the staff (in
The following example, from a keyboard sonata by Joseph Haydn, shows a trill with concluding grace notes (called Nachschlag):
220.127.116.11. Special Cases
Symbols and abbreviations for trills have changed and evolved considerably throughout history. Strategies to clarify the encoding and interpretation of ornaments have been discussed in section
Overriding Default Resolutions above. However, in order to aid the encoder in making educated choices in the encoding of non-standard trills, this section shows two examples diverging from modern standard use.
The abbreviation “tr” followed by a wavy line spanning multiple notes is sometimes used to indicate multiple trills:
The encoding of this kind of trill may vary depending on the purpose of the encoding. For representation of the source, a single trill is sufficient:
To support analytical and aural rendering applications, however, each trill may be explicitly encoded, as the following example demonstrates:
However, when it is necessary to support multiple outputs, use of the
choice element and appropriate sub-elements is recommended. In this case, the
reg elements can be used to represent the original source and a regularization provided by the editor, respectively:
Another situation that requires disambiguation of an ornament’s name and its potential rendition is due to the fact that the symbols for trills and mordents have been often used interchangeably in the past. The following example, taken from Klavierbüchlein für Wilhelm Friedemann Bach (1720), shows a trill (Trillo) identified by the symbol associated with a mordent in modern practice. Nonetheless, J.S. Bach’s suggested resolution should be encoded with a variant of the procedure presented above.
In the example below, the child elements of
choice; that is,
reg, represent non-exclusive options; that is, both may be processed by applications that aim to support both visual and aural renditions.
Depending on the purpose of the encoding, it may be more convenient to encode the regularized text within the stream of events, along with a corresponding choice with regard to the existence of the trill marking, as in the following example:
orig element contains the single-note-with-trill transcription of the original text, while the
reg element represents the realization-without-trill version.
This approach facilitates substitution of the realization of the trill for the original written note (as well as the opposite procedure) and is therefore the recommended markup for applications where exchange of this kind is desirable.
A turn is an ornament that typically consists of four notes: the upper neighbor of the principal note, the principal note, the lower neighbor, and the principal note again.
The presence of a turn is encoded with the
turn element and its attributes:
Records the written accidental associated with an upper neighboring note.
It is recommended, but not required, to use the attribute @form to encode the typology of the turn.
The attribute @form accepts the following values:
upper: usually corresponding to the symbol:
. This turn is commonly performed beginning on a note higher than the principal note.
lower: usually corresponding to the symbol:
. This turn is commonly performed beginning on a note lower than the principal note.
The following example shows the encoding of a simple turn:
Turns can sometimes be performed after the principal note (usually on the second half of the beat, see Read 1979, p. 246) and leading to the following event. To indicate this, the turn symbol is typically written in between the principal note and the next. These kind of turns are encoded with the attribute @delayed.
The following example from Beethoven’s piano sonata no. 1 in F minor, op. 2, no. 1, mvmt. 2 demonstrates the encoding of turns with the @delayed attribute. Note that the @tstamp attribute indicates the actual starting point in time, while @startid points to the principal note.
4.4.5. Other Ornaments
CMN ornaments that are not mordents, trills, or turns can be encoded with a generic
This element allows the encoder to represent ornaments as textual strings (e.g. with a Unicode symbol) or with a user defined symbol. Chromatic auxiliaries can be represented with @accidlower and @accidupper. The
ornam element can also be a control element. That is, it can be linked via its attributes to other events. The starting point of the directive may be indicated by either a tstamp, tstamp.ges, tstamp.real or startid attribute, while the ending point may be recorded by either a tstamp2, dur, dur.ges or endid attribute. It is a semantic error not to specify a starting point attribute.
For example, Johann Sebastian Bach used non-standard ornaments in the Klavierbüchlein für Wilhelm Friedemann Bach:
The ornament for (5) doppelt-cadence could be encoded in the following way, by adopting the Unicode code-points defined by the SMuFL standard:
A resolution, or expansion of the ornament can be provided as discussed in
Special Cases below.
4.4.6. Ornaments in Combinations
Particularly in baroque keyboard music, but also in the early classical period, various combinations of ornaments can be found. Despite being written vertically above the same note, they are to be performed in sequence.
When encoding the example above, both ornaments will be positioned above the same note. The encoded order of the elements, moreover, may correspond to the performed sequence, which in this example is top to bottom: first the turn, then the mordent. As every renderer deals differently with such combined ornaments it is best practice to encode the performed sequence additionally with @next and @prev attributes. The visual order can be specified globally with @aboveorder in the preceding